Binomial Tree

  • Thread starter Thread starter matiz
  • Start date Start date
Joined
3/7/11
Messages
15
Points
13
Hi,

I have started reading Options, Futures and Other Derivatives by John C Hull with the aim of gaining knowledge in this area. Chapter 10 - one step Binomail model considers a portfolio consisting of a long position in delta shares of a stock and a short position of one call option. I do not understand the bass of considering this portfolio - also why has the author considered delta or fractional shares for this portfolio? It might be a basic question, but as I am new to this field - any help would be greatly appreciated

Thanks,
 
For hedging purposes. Short call is being hedged by the long position in delta shares. Consider it this way: you have shorted the call. So you are loosing when price increases. You have unlimited loss since the spot moves beyond the strike. So the call writer has to hedge the position by longing delta shares. (where delta is the first derivative of black-sholes formula on spot.) So the writer has 0 gain on the maturity(or expiration date in case of Amercan call) which is the idea of delta hedging. Idea is simple. The possible loss in call must be eliminated by the price appreciation in shares you are holding.
 
If you don't understand why there must be the 0 gain for the writer of call(investment bank) I'll briefly explain: When underwriter writes call option, it must NOT be exposed to any risk, so it just takes the service charge which is the transaction fee. So it is not compensated for any risk taken (since he is going risk free). But since the shorted call has the unlimited loss when spot goes beyond strike, it should hedge the risk to get the "calm sleep" (provide riskless service). So it has to come up with the method to eliminate the possible risk by spot being appreciated. It must purchase the opposite moving asset-which is the shares themselves. Delta amount gives the IB exact amount of shares to be shorted to receive 0 gain after expiration. Constant re-hedging strategy is another point so I won't go now through the Merton model and so on. Hope you got the point.

When you see the option prices quoted on CME, they are not the black-sholes calculated price or derived by binomial method in case of American options. They are that fair price(calculated by BS or binomial) plus the transaction fee to be paid to underwriter. So if BS or binomial stated the option price should be $2.00, you will probably see the actual premium quoted to be for example #2.30. And that difference #0.3 is the transaction fee.
 
Hi Tsotne,

Thanks for the reply. I understood everthing except "where delta is the first derivative of black-sholes formula on spot." I know what derivativs are, but not sure on the black soles formula on spot. I guess I have to keep reading.
 
Hi Tsotne,

Thanks for the reply. I understood everthing except "where delta is the first derivative of black-sholes formula on spot." I know what derivativs are, but not sure on the black soles formula on spot. I guess I have to keep reading.

Hello again.

Δ measures the rate of change of option value with respect to changes in the underlying asset's price. Delta is the first derivative of the value V of the option with respect to the underlying instrument's price S. When IB has shorted the call, it has to long shares to eliminate the shorted call's risk right?! - as we agreed in above posts, but how many shares does it have to long? That number is exactly delta. Put another way, find the mathematical derivative of the blacksholes formula with respect to spot, and the outcome is nothing more than delta - the number of shares to to long in order to be in a riskless (delta neutral) position.

delta1.png


If you further have any question feel free to ask. ;) Best
Tsotne
 
I'll in sequence state the steps for one hypothetical problem to make everything clear and hope that helps you to understand. Suppose for simplicity that we deal with European call right now.

1) Someone goes to the IB and buys the call option on the XYZ common stock. So IB has shorted the call and puts itself in such situation:

short-call-options-strategy.jpg


As you see the loss is unlimited as XYZ (or spot) price moves beyond strike. But investment bank doesn't take any risk, thus is only compensated for the service it provide to clients - to be more specific- selling call option. But in this figure we see that IB not only has the risk of loosing money - but it has unlimited risk of loosing. For example if spot price reaches $135 the corresponding loss will be $1500. For $140 spot there will be a loss of approx $2000 and so on. So it has to hedge the position. In this case by delta hedging.

2) Delta hedging strategy:

That said, IB has to purchase the opposite moving shares (opposite of call). What can you think of such assets are? - Underlying shares themselves right?! YES. So it buys the shares and now it is in the following position. Please don't pay attention to the price scale it is another stock I found, but for the sake of illustration its ok:

long-stock-short-call.gif


As you see the possible spot price increase is eliminated by the shares holdings. So IB is in a riskless position. That is, whatever happens to the spot price, IB always receives 0 return after expiration. So we have perfectly hedged the short position by going long in underlying shares. As I have suspected, you probably came up with the question: What amount of shares does IB purchases(longs) in order to hedge the position. The answer is, this amount:

delta1.png

And it's logical. Suppose what happens if IB doesn't exactly longs the delta amount of shares. First case: it buys more than delta shares. Then it has run into the underlying risk, of course IB is holding more than necessary for hedging and if underlying ZYX goes down, it losses. Second, if it longs less than delta amount then it hasn't fully hedged position in short call and has the possibility of loss on the number short calls which haven't been hedged. Put another way, shares weren't enough to eliminate all short calls' risk.

3) We reach the expiration date.

When the expiration date comes and Option expires, IB has a 0 gain regardless of anything that has happened. Spot price increase/decrease possibilities have been hedged by finding opposite moving assets(in this case underlying shares). So you might have come up with another question: Is Investment Bank such stupid that he operates till the expiration date for you and receives 0 gain? Answer is: Of course not. Black-Sholes or binomial method calculates a FAIR price to be paid on option. So again, if the premium of call option quoted on CME is $2.30, you must assume that this is not a fair price, rather, it is a fair price (derived by BS or Binomial) plus the service charge IB conducts called transaction fee. So when you purchase option, you pay both $2.00 fair premium and + $0.3 transaction fee.

4)Here they (IB and client) have already broken the relationship since expiration date has been passed. But you might have another question. How often does the delta hedging occurs? This is completely another topic and if you are interested tell me and I'll try to provide such steps. But typically after the opening day, they know the previous day's close prices and so they immediately hedge in the morning every trading day till maturity comes.

Back to your question :
I understood everthing except "where delta is the first derivative of black-sholes formula on spot."
Is it that you confused with financial derivatives(instruments) with mathematical derivative?

Again, delta is the mathematical derivative of blacksholes formula(option price) with respect to spot(underlying).

Hope you got the point of delta hedging.

Regards
Tsotne
 
Hi Tsotne,

Makes so much more sense. thanks a ton for the detailed explanation.

Regards,

Matiz
 
Back
Top Bottom