CMU MSCF CMU MSCF Admission Discussion

[stupidyl]

Hi guys, does anyone have any clue how many admissions will be reserved in the third round? Kinda of anxious as I am in the 3rd round. Also, any difference in the admission requirements between the 3rd round and first two rounds? Thank you.

 

[Benjamin H]

Hi guys, does anyone have any clue how many admissions will be reserved in the third round? Kinda of anxious as I am in the 3rd round. Also, any difference in the admission requirements between the 3rd round and first two rounds? Thank you.

I think there will still be many admits in the 3rd round. According to the tracker, many admits came in May last year. And I think the admission standard is dependent on how many applications received and how many spots is still available. Every school/program has a targeted number of students.

 

[Nevaloselondon]

I feel so depressed right now. I stayed up for the entire night and when I did my interview, I could bearly respond to any of the questions. I have definitely missed out on the opportunity to get into Carnegie.

 

[Jonas_Nie]

I feel so depressed right now. I stayed up for the entire night and when I did my interview, I could bearly respond to any of the questions. I have definitely missed out on the opportunity to get into Carnegie.

Take it esay, dude. Maybe Rick or Gwen just thought adversely.

 

[bullion]

I feel so depressed right now. I stayed up for the entire night and when I did my interview, I could bearly respond to any of the questions. I have definitely missed out on the opportunity to get into Carnegie.

that's too bad. I bet Carnegie would've also been perfect for you and most likely the only way out of your matchbox office or suffocating classroom. What can you do with yourself now after knowing your life has been ruined at such young age due to one completely avoidable mistake which you're solely responsible? What will you do now when the single most critical turning point and catalyst to your fortune and identity has been ruined by mere sleep deprivation? Oh the despair, sorrow, and shame. If there's only a permanent solution to this pain as it is too hard to bear...

Or you can.... iono, chill out? There are plenty of other schools to get quality education from.

 

[Nevaloselondon]

I have a couple of offers already so I am okay but I just really like carnegie but I am still praying.

 

[Sushant]

I have a couple of offers already so I am okay but I just really like carnegie but I am still praying.

I think it's best to be optimistic and hope for the best. Best of luck.

 

[remylebeau]

Hey guys, this is a question for those who have been admitted to Columbia and also have a Round 2 interview with CMU. I've just been asked this by a fellow member and I don't have any good answer, so I thought I'd throw the question open to everyone here:


CMU's admission decisions will only be out on 2 Apr. However, Columbia requires us to accept or decline their offer by 30 Mar. Does anyone have any suggestion on how to go about resolving this quandary? A few options:

1) Pay the USD2,500 confirmation fee to Columbia to secure the spot first.
2) Ask Columbia for an extension.
3) Ask CMU for an early decision.
4) TAKE THE RISK. Decline Columbia's offer and be on tenterhooks for 3 days while waiting for CMU's decision.

What do you guys think? Is CMU open to releasing early decisions? (I got the distinct impression that they don't.) Will Columbia look kindly on students who ask for an extension? (I doubt that as well.)

All are welcome to give us some suggestions!

 

[AndrewChang]

Hey guys, this is a question for those who have been admitted to Columbia and also have a Round 2 interview with CMU. I've just been asked this by a fellow member and I don't have any good answer, so I thought I'd throw the question open to everyone here:


CMU's admission decisions will only be out on 2 Apr. However, Columbia requires us to accept or decline their offer by 30 Mar. Does anyone have any suggestion on how to go about resolving this quandary? A few options:

1) Pay the USD2,500 confirmation fee to Columbia to secure the spot first.
2) Ask Columbia for an extension.
3) Ask CMU for an early decision.
4) TAKE THE RISK. Decline Columbia's offer and be on tenterhooks for 3 days while waiting for CMU's decision.

What do you guys think? Is CMU open to releasing early decisions? (I got the distinct impression that they don't.) Will Columbia look kindly on students who ask for an extension? (I doubt that as well.)

All are welcome to give us some suggestions!

I disagree... I think both Columbia and CMU will be quite lenient with their policy. You can probably use the fact that you got into Columbia as leverage of getting into CMU.

Remember that this is a business and that both CMU and Columbia want you to be a student if you are good enough.

 

[darth]

Tepper-Gwen: ​

​

@Shuo - Unfortunately no, we do not release decisions earlier. We make our application deadlines and notifications very public and we stick to those deadlines. It does take us some time to do a thorough review of applications and want to make sure we do our due diligence in reviewing all applications. I would recommend asking for an extension from other programs. This is a common request that we receive and I know one that I am generally willing to work with students to accommodate.​

QN chat​

 

[bullion]

darth, do you just keep track of all the past chat responses? I mean it's kinda cool but.... also a bit scary

 

[darth]

No...dun wry Its just that I happen to attend this chat and due to my nature of work, over the years I have developed a photographic memory ... Btw I did not understand the scary part

 

[bullion]

darth I don't remember the last time I save a chat and being able to recite it... and what kind work DEVELOPS a photographic memory? man I need to get on that!

 

[Andy Nguyen]

Just tell them you are waiting for decisions from CMU.

 

[vsolanki]

Hello Gwen/AdCom/Forum members,

I am applying for part time MSCF in NY, Fall 2012. I know that the R4 deadline is Apr 23rd and I am trying my best to finish my application by then. I have recommender's invitation sent out and have started working on the essays. I was wondering if you know what chance do I stand to get into the part time program so late in the process ( below are my credentials ) and also if you have any pointers on the application process. Really appreciate your time and assistance

GMAT - 710 ( Q: 49, V: 37 )
Undergrad GPA - ~3.85 ( equivalent of 70% in India )
Masters in Computer Science - GPA 3.9 ( SUNY Binghamton )
Work Ex: Total 7.4 yrs - 6 yrs in Goldman Sachs - Interest Rate Product trading technology.

Thanks
An Eager Candidate

 

[DeltaVega]

had my interview today... it wasn't exactly a laid back relaxed chat, there was no math, but Gwen asked some interesting behavioral questions that reminded me of my job interviews, and the appointment lasted more than 30 minutes... i'm guessing this year the "interview = 90% admit" rule is no longer in effect

 

[jianpu]

had my interview today... it wasn't exactly a laid back relaxed chat, there was no math, but Gwen asked some interesting behavioral questions that reminded me of my job interviews, and the appointment lasted more than 30 minutes... i'm guessing this year the "interview = 90% admit" rule is no longer in effect

that's because your interviewer is Gwen.... haha

 

[DeltaVega]

so what's the difference between her and Rick... actually isn't Rick more senior and so should be stricter?

 

[jianpu]

rick did not ask many questions, that's the difference

 

[DeltaVega]

either way, Gwen was pretty cool, she made the conversation as interesting and laid back as possible, despite her asking the un-orthodox questions she asked... and i am certain the yes/no decision will come jointly from both her and Rick

jianpu did you apply for CMU? did you do you interview with Rick? how was it if so?