- Joined
- 5/9/12
- Messages
- 46
- Points
- 18
Hi, my name is Jay Kim and I was wondering if I can get some advice about the quantile on normal distribution and log-normal distribution.
According to one of the Coursera lecture I'm taking recently,
if
r ~ N(mean, SD^2)
and
R = exp(r) - 1
then
R ~ logN(mean, SD^2)
furthermore
Quantile on R with alpha = exp(Quantile on r with alpha) - 1
But I somehow intuitively thought that it is not correct,
and I checked myself the calculations using R.
And it turned out that the R function
plnorm(exp(Quantile on r with alpha) - 1, mean, SD)
does not give me alpha at all. The result is zero, not some positive value of alpha. (In this case, my alpha was 0.05)
But it should be alpha according to the lecture. I'm here very confused.
exp(qnorm(alpha, mean, SD)) - 1
and
qlnorm(alpha, mean, SD)
are not the same either, which is very opposite of what the lecturer said.
I was wondering what kinds of mistakes I've made here.
Quantile on R with alpha = exp(Quantile on r with alpha) - 1
Is above equation really correct?
Or should I conclude that the lecturer taught me something wrong?
I would appreciate you help.. Thank you.
According to one of the Coursera lecture I'm taking recently,
if
r ~ N(mean, SD^2)
and
R = exp(r) - 1
then
R ~ logN(mean, SD^2)
furthermore
Quantile on R with alpha = exp(Quantile on r with alpha) - 1
But I somehow intuitively thought that it is not correct,
and I checked myself the calculations using R.
And it turned out that the R function
plnorm(exp(Quantile on r with alpha) - 1, mean, SD)
does not give me alpha at all. The result is zero, not some positive value of alpha. (In this case, my alpha was 0.05)
But it should be alpha according to the lecture. I'm here very confused.
exp(qnorm(alpha, mean, SD)) - 1
and
qlnorm(alpha, mean, SD)
are not the same either, which is very opposite of what the lecturer said.
I was wondering what kinds of mistakes I've made here.
Quantile on R with alpha = exp(Quantile on r with alpha) - 1
Is above equation really correct?
Or should I conclude that the lecturer taught me something wrong?
I would appreciate you help.. Thank you.
Last edited: