Can you clarify your points about some metrics being 2 years lag?
To your point about having some sort of input from recent students, I think it would benefit prospective students as far as having a deeper insight into the programs.
This is the exact reason I have tried to get as much alumni reviews as possible. As you can see on the ranking page, some programs only have a handful of reviews despite enrolling over a hundred students every year for the past 20 years. This tells me the quantity and quality are not there. It's not for a lack of trying from all stakeholders.
I love hearing feedback from all our members who have benefited from the insights that our rankings provide.
Regarding the 2 (now that I think about it, 3) year gap:
For the students currently applying to Quant Masters programs, they are looking at the 2025 rankings to assist with their decisions. I attend a program that requires 36 credits, or 1.5 years, for completion. Therefore, the students from my program who are represented in the rankings are the students who graduated in 2023, while prospective students are going to graduate in 2026. With the volatility in the job market, finding a job in 2026 will look much different than in 2023.
I understand that there will be inconsistencies in the metrics, but that's where I believe that there should be input from current/alumni about the day-to-day of the program. With the program reviews that you mentioned, I am a fan of the three ratings that are provided: Students Quality, Courses/Instructors, and Career Services. Perhaps, QuantNet can incorporate a weighted sum of these ratings as a metric in the rankings. Unfortunately, as you mentioned, there are only a handful of students who have submitted reviews. If there is a way to substantially increase this number (mass email? LinkedIn campaign? coordination from schools?), incorporating some feedback about student satisfaction will definitely improve prospective students' decision making.
With this one critique, I am incredibly thankful for all the work that QuantNet does for students/young professionals who want to break into the quantitative finance industry. Keep up the great work!